I'm sorry, did I forgot to make up my mind again?
I was sure I would vote Banj when he posted his final. And then Val posted his and I wasn't sure anymore
In other words, whenever I don't vote in time, it's all your fault
That said, I agree with your feedback for each other.
The cookbook looks a bit small and paper backish, for the given situation. I think I might have also placed both the wooden thingies to the right on the counter/table. Right now it's a bit of an in your face path tp the book and I think I'd have found the image more balanced with them both to the right.
And Val's water surface is disturbingly undisturbed for having just been breached by that spacecraft... I also think the vague figure of Luke somehow looks a bit too much like C3P0 there in the back. Something about the pose - and probably the proximity of R2D2. I'm impressed by the sculpting of Yoda's face, though. (I might try - sorry, do - I might do some Blender sculpting for the current challenge. Maybe. We'll see...)
But I am almost forgetting to vote again. I guess I should, even if it's late?
I think I still vote Banj - because it all looks so real. (You don't have all that stuff standing in your basement, bought at some convention, do you?
)